
CCP Global Annual Markets Review
Annual Markets Review (AMR)
The CCP Global AMR provides exclusive insights and in-depth analysis covering key market trends, risk management, and regulatory developments from a clearing house perspective. The AMR reports provide detailed analyses of global clearing dynamics, PQD statistics, margining strategies, liquidity trends, and systemic risk considerations. Explore the dedicated case studies from major clearing houses, offering unique insights into their operations, policies, and innovations shaping the industry. These reports deliver the critical intelligence needed to navigate the evolving landscape of central clearing.
By Year

May 2024 | Annual Markets Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. GLOBAL ECONOMIC LANDSCAPE IN 2023
1.1 THE YEAR IN CHARTS: KEY ECONOMIC INDICATORS, TRENDS, AND SELECTED MARKET EVENTS DURING 2023
2. CCP REGULATORY CONTEXT AND MARKET PRACTICES DEVELOPMENTS IN 2023
2.1 CCP STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS
2.2 CCP RECOVERY AND RESOLUTION REGIMES
2.3 REGULATORY DEVELOPMENTS IMPACTING CENTRAL CLEARING
2.4 DEFAULT MANAGEMENT AUCTIONS
2.7 CCP SUPERVISORY STRESS TESTS
2.8 CCP OPERATIONAL RISK MANAGEMENT
3. CCP DATA AND RESILIENCE IN 2023
3.2 IM, VM, AND DEFAULT FUND ANALYSIS
3.3 CCP CORE SYSTEM AVAILABILITY AND OTHER STATISTICS
3.4 CCP GLOBAL PQD QUARTERLY TRENDS REPORT
Case Studies

ASX
Forecasting Peak Trade Volume Using a Hybrid Long-Term Trend and Jump Model
Securities transacted on Australian cash equity markets are settled via the Clearing House Electronic Sub-register System (“CHESS”), which is operated by the Australian Securities Exchange (“ASX”). CHESS provides several critical functions, including clearing and delivery versus payment (“DvP”) settlement, an electronic sub-register for shares in listed companies and other securities, as well as other post trade services critical to the orderly functioning of the market.
In November 2023, ASX announced its decision to partner with global technology provider TATA Consultancy Services to design and deliver a new CHESS. The indicative time-frame for the delivery of the full system is 2028-2029, subject to a number of factors including stakeholder consultation and detailed planning. Until then, ASX will continue to invest in the capacity and resilience of the existing CHESS, to ensure that it can reliably process current and future trade volumes, including during periods of elevated trade activity such as was seen during the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.
To assist with future capacity planning, the Securities and Payments team at ASX required a reliable forecast of future peak daily trade volume, extending out to 10 years. This paper describes a hybrid forecasting model which was developed by ASX’s Risk Quantification Team for this purpose. The model is based on a combination of time-series modelling for long-term trade volume growth, and a jump process to model infrequent but significant volume spikes. The model has been calibrated using 16 years of historical daily trade volume data, and evaluated using in-sample (model-fit) and out-of-sample (backtesting) metrics, and is updated on a monthly basis.

COMDER/CRCC
How the G20 Derivatives Markets Reform Boosted the International Demand for Chilean and Colombian Derivatives
For more than 100 years, counterparty credit risk (“CCR”) management, which, among some other critical factors such as due diligence, monitoring, etc., also involves posting collateral in the form of margin, has been the key to the success of the development of the futures and options markets, or what is called listed derivatives products. However, collateral posting to mitigate CCR is relatively new in OTC derivatives products.
One of the most important consequences of the implementation of the G20 derivatives reform, in the aftermath of the GFC, was the way that large banks manage CCR for OTC derivatives, mainly because of the introduction of mandatory clearing for a large portion of derivatives products and uncleared margin rules (“UMR”). Hence, banks moved from managing CCR by means of credit lines to their clients and counterparties, to managing CCR by posting collateral either to their direct counterparties or to a CCP.
Derivatives markets are relatively new in Chile and Colombia and their development was led by local banks since the early nineties in the form of OTC derivatives. However, listed derivatives have not had the same traction and their development still lags that of OTC derivatives. This is the reason why local banks managed CCR exposure by granting credit lines to their counterparties.
Local banks in Chile and Colombia have a long history of trading with global foreign banks, particularly after the implementation of the G20 derivatives reform. Local banks faced the obligation to send derivatives to CCPs or sign Credit Support Annexes (“CSAs”) for IM and VM. Since neither Colombia nor Chile belong to the G20, no mandatory clearing or UMR was imposed on them while the G20 countries were implementing such reforms. In practical terms, local banks faced an extraterritorial regulatory situation that forced them to change the way they were used to managing CCR.
This case study will show the positive impact of the G20 derivatives market reform in Chile and Colombia. We will see how the reforms boosted volumes of derivatives transactions between local banks and foreign counterparties, which in the case of interest rate derivatives reached levels never seen before, even amid central banks actively fighting the consequences of the COVID-19 crisis, and the related spike in inflation.

EUREX CLEARING
Initial Margin Cyclicality: Measurement and Transparency
In the complex landscape of financial markets, the concept of Initial Margin (“IM”) holds a pivotal role, especially in the context of derivatives trading and risk management. IM refers to the collateral required to be posted by a party in a financial transaction to cover potential future exposure to its counterparty arising from market movements. The cyclicality of IM, characterized by its fluctuation in response to changes in market volatility and other factors, poses significant challenges and opportunities for market participants. This article provides Eurex’s views on the nuances of IM cyclicality, its measurement, and the imperative of transparency in its management. A few potential approaches to enhancing CCP transparency of the reactiveness of their margin models are presented alongside the challenges that might arise. The article concludes with Eurex’s suggestions for tangible steps CCPs and regulators could take in an effort to boost market participant liquidity preparedness.

HKEX/SHCH
Pioneering OTC Derivatives CCP Interoperability — HKEX and SHCH Clearing Link Under Swap Connect
Swap Connect, launched on 15 May 2023, is the world’s first derivatives mutual market access program. Connecting Mainland China and Hong Kong, it allows international investors for the first time to trade and clear onshore Renminbi (“RMB”) IRS while remaining offshore. This is achieved through a ground-breaking collaboration between HKEX’s clearing subsidiary OTC Clear and SHCH, bridging the derivatives clearing infrastructure across the border.
Swap Connect has implemented an innovative CCP interoperable model to reduce the complexity for onshore and offshore investors in multiple processes without having to modify their current trading and settlement practices. For clearing and settlement, a new Clearing Link has been established which enables OTC Clear and SHCH to jointly provide clearing and settlement services, with OTC Clear providing central clearing services for Hong Kong and international investors, while SHCH provides central clearing services for investors in Mainland China. For risk management, the introduction of inter-CCP margin pioneered by SHCH and OTC Clear provides sufficient coverage in a CCP default scenario. Clear default waterfall procedures in case of a CM default are well-defined; they do not envisage the use of the inter-CCP margin, and the default fund of the other interoperable CCP.
Swap Connect marks a significant milestone in the opening up of China’s financial markets. It will help further strengthen the interconnection of financial markets between Hong Kong and Mainland China and create new investment opportunities for international investors.

JSCC
First JSCC DLT-Based Production System – Launched for Physical Settlement of Commodity Futures
While the Japanese financial markets have always been of significant global importance, the listed derivatives market has particularly attracted a growing share of foreign investors recently. However, the global settlements infrastructure has not effectively reduced the underlying operational inefficiencies and its associated risks.
With the many recent technological innovations, JSCC sees an opportunity for major participants in our global financial markets to assess these operational inefficiencies and collaboratively transform our outdated ecosystems. This should be built upon a foundation of standard business processes and can be effectively delivered using robust and secure open-source software tools.
Particularly, the tokenization of assets can offer immediate benefits in many areas of today’s post-trade operational and settlement processes. In a small first step, JSCC launched its first DLT-based production system in January 2023 with the view to improve operational efficiencies using tokens in the physical settlement of rubber (“RSS”) futures. JSCC intends to influence and align with global standards to further benefit upon expanded token-based services. This case study summarizes our journey.

KDPW_CCP
Orderly Handling of the Unexpected – Recovery Planning
Entry into force of CCP recovery and resolution regulation in the EU enforced the EU CCPs to prepare their recovery plans till 12th February 2022. As the requirements regarding content of CCP’s recovery plan are based on provisions regulating banking recovery, preparing such a plan poses a significant challenge for CCPs that do not have a banking license and for the local ones, as the provisions of regulation were designed mostly for the biggest players being systemically important across the EU.
KDPW_CCP is a local CCP operating on the Polish market. KDPW_CCP is the only CCP serving the Warsaw Stock Exchange (“WSE”) by clearing in equity segment and the only CCP clearing OTC derivatives on the Polish market. We are then the primary choice of Polish clearing participants.
This case study provides an overview regarding challenges that KDPW_CCP has faced in preparing the recovery plan and the adopted solutions.

July 2023 | Annual Markets Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. GLOBAL ECONOMIC LANDSCAPE IN 2022
1.1 THE YEAR IN CHARTS: KEY ECONOMIC INDICATORS, TRENDS, AND SELECTED MARKET EVENTS DURING 2022
3. CCP REGULATORY CONTEXT AND MARKET PRACTICES DEVELOPMENTS IN 2022
3.1 NEW ASSET CLASSES OR CHANGES IN PRODUCTS’ UPTAKE IN CLEARING IN 2022
3.2 CCP STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS
3.3 CCP RECOVERY AND RESOLUTION REGIMES
3.4 CPMI AND IOSCO CLIENT CLEARING AND PORTING
3.5 CPMI AND IOSCO ANALYSIS ON CCP PRACTICES TO ADDRESS NDLs
3.6 CCP GOVERNANCE REQUIREMENTS
3.7 DEFAULT MANAGEMENT AUCTIONS
3.9 CCP THIRD PARTY RISK MANAGEMENT (“TPRM”)
3.10 CLIMATE-RELATED FINANCIAL RISK
4. CCP DATA AND RESILIENCE IN 2022
4.3 CCP CORE SYSTEM AVAILABILITY AND OTHER STATISTICS
4.4 CCP Global QUARTERLY TRENDS REPORT
Case Studies

EUREX & CME
Comparison Of Porting Mechanisms in Eu and Us Regimes
In the event of a Clearing Member default at a CCP, CCPs endeavor to transfer client positions and collateral from the defaulting Clearing Member to a non-defaulting Clearing Member, often referred to as “porting”. Porting enables the clients of the defaulting Clearing Member to maintain their exposures, ultimately providing them continuity of clearing services. However, we have observed that due to the differing regulatory frameworks (e.g., account segregation), which leads to different risk management practices at CCPs across jurisdictions, CCPs employ different approaches to porting. The two case studies that follow outline the differences in how porting may occur at Eurex Clearing, a European-based CCP, and CME Clearing, a U.S.-based CCP regulated by the CFTC.

COMDER
The Origins of Otc Trade Repositories and the Benefits of the New Derivatives Trade Repository in Chile; Personal View by Pablo Rodriguez, Cro, Comder Ccp
The opacity of the derivatives market was at the center of the stage of the GFC and fueled the panic seen during the worse days of the crisis. The American International Group (“AIG”) problems revealed during the weekend of the Lehman default demonstrated that not enough information was available about the risk exposures of large financial institutions to the derivatives instruments and other asset classes and, for that reason, regulators were ready to make the necessary changes to improve transparency of key financial firms and restore confidence in the market. The inclusion of OTC derivatives Trade Repositories (“TR”) was one of the big changes.
By centralizing the collection, storage, and dissemination of data, a TR can enhance the transparency of transaction information to relevant authorities and the public and, most importantly, they can promote financial stability.
Chilean regulators and the local financial community already benefited from the information provided by the local TR, especially to manage financial stability. Now, Chilean regulators can do stress tests of derivatives positions at the industry level, size collateral calls (especially in non-central bank money) and analyze the impact of extreme market volatility on non-bank institutions. In other words, Chilean regulators now have enough information about the risk exposures of large financial institutions in Chile.

ICE
The Implementation of Irm 2.0 at Icus
ICUS is a CFTC-registered DCO and provides clearing services for equity index, interest rates, and agricultural futures and options traded on ICE Futures U.S. which includes ICE’s benchmark MSCI® equity index futures.
ICUS traditionally used ICE Risk Model 1 (“IRM1”), a parametric model, to calculate IM requirements for all of its cleared products. However, ICUS transitioned its equity index and interest rate contracts from IRM1 to IRM2 in Q1 2022 following a 12-18 month implementation phase with regulators, CMs, vendors, and customers.
IRM2 is the result of a multi-year effort within ICE to design, develop, and implement a new portfolio-based model. Migrating to such a new risk model is a large undertaking for a CCP due to the review and approval process across relevant committees, external validators, CMs, and regulators. In addition, implementing a new risk model requires a long lead-time for CMs and vendors, to understand impact to cleared portfolios and schedule required development and testing to integrate to the new model.
This case study provides an overview of why ICUS chose to implement a new risk model and the process undertaken to migrate from IRM1 to IRM2 for the equity index and interest rate contracts.

NSE
Successful Migration to T+1 Settlement Cycle in India
Between February 2022 and January 2023, CCPs in India successfully migrated the settlement cycle for cash equities from T+2 to T+1, being one of the very few markets to achieve T+1 settlement in equities. The implementation in India is particularly remarkable considering a multilaterally netted delivery-versus-payment (“DvP”) settlement in a fully interoperable framework. Trades can be executed on any exchange, margined, and settled through any CCP, and securities transferred in any CSDs, at the choice of the market participants.
Indian FMIs implemented the necessary procedural and system changes; and were able to settle the first trade under T+1 settlement within 6 months from regulatory enablement. The securities with least market cap were put under T+1 settlement to begin with, and subsequently, all securities were incrementally migrated under T+1 over the next 1 year in the order of their market capitalization. This approach helped successfully achieve a significant change within a short span of time and without any issues.

SHANGHAI CLEARING HOUSE
A Stress Test on Legal Risk in Ccp Default Management – China’s First Financial Market Test Case
China has been committed to developing a modern legal framework for financial markets. China’s first financial court, established in Shanghai, initiated the Financial Markets Test Case Scheme. In October 2022, SHCH together with 4 CMs, jointly filed the application for a case test on major legal issues in CCP default management. The test case is the first financial market test case in China and the world’s first central clearing financial test case.
The case tests the legitimacy of SHCH’s default management rules and the rationality of the DMP. Upon completion of procedures including materials and evidence submission, information disclosure, third-parties consultation, and public trial, the Court published the judicial opinion of this test case. The judicial opinion held that SHCH default management rules met the requirements of validity and were legally binding from a judicial perspective. The Court also recognized the rationality of SHCH’s DMP.
The test case enhances the legal certainty of China’s FMIs’ rules and promotes compatibility with international financial market practices. Furthermore, it could serve as a useful reference for developing the legal framework for the cleared markets in global emerging economies.

July 2022 | Annual Markets Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.1 KEY ECONOMIC INDICATORS, TRENDS, AND SELECTED MARKET EVENTS DURING 2021
3. CCP REGULATORY CONTEXT AND MARKET PRACTICES DEVELOPMENTS IN 2021
3.1 CCP STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS
3.2 INNOVATIVE PRODUCTS AND SERVICES IN CLEARING FOR 2021
3.3 DEFAULT MANAGEMENT AUCTIONS
3.4 IOSCO, BCBS AND CPMI MARGINING PRACTICES
3.5 RECOVERY AND RESOLUTION REGIMES
3.6 CFTC MRAC’S ATTENTION ON CCP RISK AND GOVERNANCE
3.7 CPMI AND IOSCO CLIENT CLEARING AND PORTING
3.8 TRANSITION TO RISK-FREE RATES AND THE IMPACT ON CLEARING OBLIGATIONS
4. CCP DATA AND RESILIENCE IN 2021
4.2 INITIAL MARGIN, VARIATION MARGIN, AND DEFAULT FUND ANALYSIS
4.3 TRANSPARENCY OF CLEARED VS. UNCLEARED MARKETS

March 2021 | CCP12 Annual Markets Review in Central Counterparty Clearing
2020 was overshadowed by the health and economic crisis arising from the COVID-19 Crisis , so much so that what would otherwise have been remarkable news stories for the markets – transition to risk-free-rates, negative oil prices, Brexit, and key elections – have taken second stage.
This issue of the CCP Global Annual Markets Review has the COVID-19 Crisis and its effect on cleared markets as its main connecting theme, supplemented with case studies exploring salient aspects of both business-as-usual and special circumstances across our membership.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIRMAN
MESSAGE FROM THE CEO
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
3. COVID-19 GLOBAL IMPACT AND ECONOMIC RESPONSES
3.1 COVID-19 ECONOMIC IMPACT
3.2 KEY MARKET DYNAMICS DURING 2020
4. EXCHANGE TRADED DERIVATIVES MARKETS
5. OTC DERIVATIVES MARKETS
5.1 GLOBAL OTC DERIVATIVES
5.2 GLOBAL CLEARED OTC DERIVATIVES
6. CCP RESILIENCE DURING 2020
6.1 CCP CORE SYSTEM AVAILABILITY
6.2 SUCCESSFUL LIBOR TRANSITION TO RFR DURING COVID-19
7. CCP MARKET RISK MANAGEMENT STATISTICS
7.1 CCP MARGIN MODELS
7.2 INITIAL MARGIN, VARIATION MARGIN AND DEFAULT FUND ANALYSIS
8. INTRODUCTION TO THE CASE STUDIES
9. MARGIN ATTRIBUTION ANALYSIS
9.1 CASE STUDY: LCH MARGIN ATTRIBUTION ANALYSIS
10. SOFR SWITCH DURING THE CC
10.1CASE STUDY: SOFR SWITCH – CME PERSPECTIVE
10.2 CASE STUDY: SOFR SWITCH – LCH PERSPECTIVE
11. MARGIN CALL PROCESS AT CCPS
11.1 CASE STUDY: MARGIN CALL PROCESS AT EUREX
11.2 CASE STUDY: MARGIN CALL PROCESS AT JSCC
12. CCP OPERATIONAL RESILIENCE DURING A GLOBAL HEALTH CRISIS
12.1 CASE STUDY: CCP RESILIENCE AND BCP DURING THE CC AT SHCH
13. CCP LAUNCH & BUSINESS EXPANSION DURING COVID-19
13.1 CASE STUDY: SAUDI STOCK EXCHANGE LAUNCHES DERIVATIVES MARKET AND CCP
13.2 CASE STUDY: CCIL SEGREGATION ACCOUNT MIGRATION DURING CC
14. CONCLUDING CCP OBSERVATIONS FOLLOWING THE CC

February 2020 | Progress and Initiatives in OTC Derivatives – A CCP12 Report
Following the G20 Leaders’ pledge in 2009 to change the process by which non-standardized Over-The-Counter derivatives are traded, this CCP12 paper explores three exclusive case studies across Collateral, Foreign Exchange, and Interest Rate Derivatives in order to research the market dynamics and build critical insights across the derivatives markets.
The report examines in detail how market participants across the spectrum of the CCP industry are managing in this constantly evolving market. The paper explores key drivers of change currently taking place, the evolution in the bilateral and cleared markets and how Uncleared Margin Rules are affecting the industry.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
MESSAGE FROM THE CEO
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.INTRODUCTION TO THE ANALYSIS
1.1 REGULATORY TIMELINE
1.2 DATA ANALYSIS OF CLEARED MARKETS
1.3 DATA ANALYSIS OF UNCLEARED MARKETS
2.COLLATERAL OVERVIEW
2.1 DEFINING COLLATERAL
2.2 COUNTERPARTY EXPOSURES
2.3 COLLATERAL IN UNCLEARED MARKETS
2.4 COLLATERAL IN CLEARED MARKETS
2.5 INITIAL MARGIN COSTS
3.1 COLLATERAL RISK MANAGEMENT IN CLEARING
3.2 COLLATERAL RISK MANAGEMENT IN BILATERAL MARKETS
3.3 COLLATERAL HAIRCUTS IN CLEARED MARKETS
3.4 CASE STUDY: COLLATERAL MANAGEMENT AT EUREX CLEARING
3.5 CASE STUDY: COLLATERAL MANAGEMENT AT JSCC
3.6 COLLATERAL LIQUIDITY AND BUFFERS
4. FX MARKETS
4.1 FX MARKET OVERVIEW
4.2 NDF MARKET REVIEW
4.3 G5 NDF CLEARING
4.4 REGULATORY CHANGES TO PROMOTE CLEARING
4.5 CASE STUDY: FX OPTIONS AT LCH FOREXCLEAR
5. SHORT-TERM INTEREST RATE DERIVATIVES
5.1 INCREASED TRADING VOLUMES
5.2 INCREASED VOLUMES IN USD INTEREST RATE DERIVATIVES
5.3 OTHER USD IRDS
5.4 RISK FREE RATES
6. CONCLUSIONS
6.1 COLLATERAL
6.2 FX OPTIONS CLEARING
6.3 SHORT USD RATES
6.4 OVERALL CONCIUSIONS

Ten years after the G20 Leaders’ commitment to reform the OTC derivatives markets, this paper examines the progress made in the central clearing arena with an emphasis on the incentives that are in place. The report is intended to supplement the Derivatives Assessment Team of the Financial Stability Board report, ‘Incentives to centrally clear over-the-counter derivatives’.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. MARKET OVERVIEW
1.1 CENTRAL CLEARING RATES OF OUTSTANDING TRADES
1.2 MARKET STRUCTURE-COMPRESSION AND BACKLOADING
1.3 CURRENT CLEARING RATES
1.4 INITIAL MARGIN HELD AT CCPS
1.5 UNCLEARED MARKETS
2. TRADE PROCESSING
2.1 TRADE PROCESSING OF NON-CLEARED TRADES
2.2 TRADE PROCESSING OF CLEARED TRADES
2.3 TRADE PROCESSING CONCLUSIONS
3. CASE STUDIES
3.1 CASE STUDY SUMMARY
3.2 ASSET CLASS COMMENTARY
3.3 FOREIGN EXCHANGE
3.4 OTC INTEREST RATE DERIVATIVES
3.5 NON-DELIVERABLE FORWARDS AT LCH FOREXCLEAR
3.6 CROSS CURRENCY SWAPS AT HKEX
3.7 LATAM RATES AT CME
4. COST COMPARISONS
4.1 PRE-TRADE
4.2 TRADE MAINTENANCE
4.3 POST-TRADE
4.4 CAPITAL ANALYSIS
4.5 DEFAULT FUND CONTRIBUTIONS
5. CONCLUSIONS
5.1 CLEARING RATES
5.2 TRADE PROCESSING
5.3 CASE STUDIES
5.4 COSTS
5.5 FURTHER STUDIES